What Are Common Asphalt Shingle Problems in East Idaho?

What sun, cold and wind do to asphalt shingles here, how to spot the problems from the ground, and which ones a treatment can't help.

The small stone granules on the surface of an asphalt shingle, up close

Watch for cracked, curled, lifted or missing shingles and bare spots.

Those are the common ones. Shingles also dry out and shed granules as they age. Cracks, curls, lifted or missing shingles and bare spots mean the roof needs a repair before anything else.

Here, a dry climate, hot summers, cold winters and strong wind all wear on a roof, and hail can do damage in one storm.

The lower edge of a shingle roof and its white gutter, with lawn beyond
The lower edge of our roof and its gutter: the part you can see from the yard.

What to Watch For From the Ground

You don't need to climb up to check. Look from the ground or an upstairs window, and look again after a windstorm. Watch for:

  • Shingles that are curled, cracked or lifted at the edges
  • Missing or torn shingles
  • Bare spots where the granules are gone
  • Granules piling up in the gutters or at the downspouts
  • Water stains on a ceiling or in the attic

Granule Loss

An asphalt shingle is a mat coated in asphalt, with granules pressed into the top. The asphalt keeps water out. The granules cover the asphalt and shade it from the sun.

As the asphalt ages and hardens, it holds granules less well. Every granule that comes loose leaves a little more asphalt exposed, so the aging speeds up.

Granules coming loose on shingles that are still whole is one thing. Once the mat shows through in bare spots, the roof needs a repair first, and no treatment changes that. How much granule loss is too much

Rows of charcoal, grey and brown asphalt shingles in sunlight, with a roof vent and trees behind

Sun, Heat and Cold

Sunlight, heat and oxygen slowly change the asphalt. It hardens and loses its flex. A dark roof in direct sun gets much hotter than the air, then cools off again, day after day.

Sunlight gets stronger the higher you go, and Idaho Falls sits at about 4,700 feet, so a roof here gets stronger sun than one near sea level.

Asphalt also moves with the temperature. A young, flexible shingle handles that fine. An older, hardened one is more likely to crack, and cold makes a brittle shingle easier to break. Heat from below counts too: a poorly ventilated attic can add heat to the shingles from underneath.

Our Weather in Plain Numbers

Long-term figures for Idaho Falls.

Idaho Falls climate: Western Regional Climate Center normals for 1981 to 2010, and Wikipedia for elevation and climate type
MeasureIdaho Falls
Average high in January30.7°F
Average high in July87.2°F
Precipitation, rain and melted snowAbout 14 inches a year
Climate typeSemi-arid
ElevationAbout 4,700 feet

That's more than 55 degrees between an average January afternoon and an average July afternoon, on top of the swing from day to night. Shingles live through all of it.

A grey asphalt shingle hip roof over white lap siding, shrubs and a lawn
A slope of dark grey asphalt shingles with a dormer's shadow at the top and a corner of lawn
A slope of our roof, with a dormer's shadow across it.

Wind and Lifted Shingles

In November 2022, a high wind warning for eastern Idaho forecast gusts above 55 mph from Atomic City through Idaho Falls, according to East Idaho News.

Strong gusts can catch the edge of a shingle and lift it. Seal strips are what hold each shingle down to the one below it, and old, hardened seal strips may not grip as well as they used to.

A shingle that's already lifted, creased or torn off is damage, not aging. That needs a repair, not a treatment.

Hail

Hail is the other big one here, and it can do its damage in a single storm. Can rejuvenation fix hail or storm damage?

When Treatment May Help, and When It Won't

Where it may help

  • Shingles slowly hardening and drying out from sun and heat
  • Granules starting to come loose on shingles that are still whole
  • Older seal strips on shingles that still lie flat

Where it won't

  • Hail, impact or wind damage
  • Missing, torn or lifted shingles
  • Leaks or water getting in
  • Soft decking (the wood under the shingles)

Rejuvenation is maintenance, not a repair. If your roof is past that point, we'll tell you.

Want the full picture? Here's what roof rejuvenation is and what it won't do. Ask us about yours. We do roof rejuvenation in Shelley and around East Idaho.

Ask for an estimate

Two quick steps, and we will call or text you back.

Step 1 of 2: your roof
Is your roof asphalt shingles?

Not sure your roof qualifies? Check the fit list.

Step 2 of 2: how to reach you
Call or text?

We only use these details to reply about your roof. Privacy

Wondering How Your Roof Is Holding Up?

Call or text your address to (208) 731-9437, Monday to Saturday, 7 am to 6 pm. We'll tell you whether it looks like a good candidate.

Send your roof details instead